New York CitySubscribe

Guide

DSCR vs. Debt Yield vs. Cap Rate: How Lenders Size a Loan

DSCR, debt yield and cap rate explained with formulas, a worked NYC-style example and a free calculator that shows which lender test limits your loan.

Brick apartment building facade in Brooklyn

Three ratios decide how much a commercial lender will lend against a building, and every one of them starts with the same number: net operating income (NOI), the rent a property collects minus its operating costs, before any mortgage payments.

  • Cap rate compares that income to the property’s value.
  • DSCR (debt service coverage ratio) compares it to the annual loan payments.
  • Debt yield compares it to the loan amount itself.

A loan has to pass every test the lender sets. Whichever one produces the smallest loan is the one that “binds,” and it’s often not the one borrowers watch.

NOI ÷ valueCap rateWhat the building earns on its price
NOI ÷ paymentsDSCRHow many times income covers the mortgage
NOI ÷ loanDebt yieldThe lender's return if it took the building

Try it: the three ratios and your maximum loan

Cap rate–NOI ÷ value
DSCR–NOI ÷ annual debt service
Debt yield–NOI ÷ loan
Loan-to-value–Loan ÷ value

Annual debt service: –

Largest loan at 80% LTV, 1.25x DSCR, 10% debt yield

  • LTV test
  • DSCR test
  • Debt yield test

The three test levels are common examples, not any lender's terms. Education only; lenders define NOI and value their own way.

Cap rate: income against value

Cap rate = NOI ÷ price (or value). A building bought for $8 million that earns $440,000 of NOI trades at a 5.5% cap rate. The cap rate says nothing about the loan. It’s the starting point: the unlevered return a buyer gets for the price paid, and the number appraisers and brokers use to compare buildings.

When cap rates rise, values fall for the same income, and a loan that was 65% of the old value becomes a larger share of the new one. That’s how a building that never missed a payment can end up underwater.

DSCR: can the income pay the mortgage?

DSCR = NOI ÷ annual debt service (all principal and interest paid in a year).

A DSCR of 1.00x means the building earns exactly enough to make its loan payments, with nothing left over. Lenders want a cushion. Fannie Mae’s conventional multifamily loans, for example, are published with a minimum of 1.25x: income at least 25% above the payments.

Because debt service depends on the interest rate and how fast the loan amortizes, DSCR moves when rates move, even if the building doesn’t change at all.

Debt yield: what the lender earns if it takes the keys

Debt yield = NOI ÷ loan amount. It ignores the interest rate, the amortization schedule and the loan term. Think of it as the cap rate on the loan: if the lender foreclosed and owned the building outright, this is the return its money would earn.

Commercial lenders adopted it during and after the financial crisis as an extra limit on loan size. Unlike DSCR, it can’t be improved by a lower interest rate or an interest-only period. Commonly reported minimums run from about 8% to 10% for stabilized properties.

DSCR changes when…

  • Interest rates rise or fall
  • The loan is interest-only instead of amortizing
  • The amortization period is longer or shorter
  • NOI changes

Debt yield changes only when…

  • NOI changes
  • The loan amount changes
  • Rates and loan terms don't move it at all

Worked example: an $8 million apartment building

A hypothetical walk-up bought for $8,000,000 with $440,000 of NOI asks for a $5,200,000 loan at 6.5%, amortizing over 30 years. All figures are calculated in code. Estimate

Test Result Common minimum Pass?
Loan-to-value 65.0% 80% maximum ✓
Annual debt service $394,410
DSCR 1.12x 1.25x ✗
Debt yield 8.46% 10% ✗

On loan-to-value alone the loan looks conservative. But the income only covers the payments 1.12 times, and the lender’s money would earn 8.5% if it had to take the building back. So how big a loan does this income actually support?

Largest loan each test allows Estimate
80% loan-to-value80% loan-to-value: $6,400,000$6,400,0001.25x DSCR1.25x DSCR: $4,640,851$4,640,85110% debt yield10% debt yield: $4,400,000$4,400,000azzets.com

Our calculation: $440,000 NOI, $8M value, 6.5% rate, 30-year amortization. Chart: Azzets

The debt-yield test binds: the most this building supports at those three limits is $4,400,000, or 55.0% of the price, not the $5,200,000 the buyer wanted. The buyer has to bring more equity, find more income, or find a lender with looser limits.

What a 1-point rate move does

At 7.5% instead of 6.5%, the same $5,200,000 loan costs $436,310 a year, and DSCR falls to 1.01x: barely covering the payments. Debt yield stays at 8.46%. That’s the point of debt yield: it doesn’t move with rates.

Interest-only flatters DSCR

Make the same loan interest-only at 6.5% and annual payments drop to $338,000, lifting DSCR to 1.30x. The building is no safer, which is why many lenders also test debt yield or underwrite DSCR on an amortizing basis.

How this shows up in NYC deals

New York apartment buildings with the city skyline behind them

When we rebuild a deal in a Deal File, city records give us the loan amount (from the recorded mortgage) and the price (from the deed), so loan-to-value is easy to compute. NOI is usually not public, so DSCR and debt yield often can’t be calculated from records alone, and we say so instead of guessing. When a seller’s loan was close to the sale price, as in our 2 Grand Central Tower file, that’s a sign the lender’s tests were under pressure long before the sale.

To see the recorded loans on any building, try Building Check.

Going further: a full multi-year model

The three ratios are a first screen. A full underwriting model projects income, expenses, the loan and a sale year by year, and that’s usually built in a spreadsheet or in dedicated software. One long-running desktop option is Real Estate Wealth Builder’s Advanced Property Analysis (paid link), which its maker says has been in development for more than 25 years. We haven’t tested it, so compare it with a spreadsheet you build yourself before paying for anything.

Education only, not investment or lending advice. Lenders define NOI, value and debt service in their own ways, and their requirements vary by property type, market and program.

FAQ

Is it better to have a higher or lower debt yield?

Higher is safer for the lender: more income per dollar lent. A lender with a 10% minimum will lend at most $1 for every $0.10 of NOI.

Is a DSCR of 1.7x good?

It means income covers the payments 1.7 times, comfortably above a 1.25x minimum such as the one published for Fannie Mae's conventional multifamily loans. Whether it's "good" depends on how reliable the income is.

What's the difference between DSCR and debt yield?

DSCR divides NOI by the annual loan payments, so it depends on the interest rate and amortization. Debt yield divides NOI by the loan amount, so it doesn't.

How do I calculate the maximum loan from a debt yield?

Divide NOI by the minimum debt yield. With $440,000 of NOI and a 10% minimum: $440,000 ÷ 0.10 = $4,400,000.

What is a good cap rate?

There isn't a single number. Cap rates vary by location, property type, building quality and interest rates. A lower cap rate means buyers pay more for each dollar of income.

Sources

Show sources (3)
  1. Fannie Mae DUS: Conventional Properties term sheet (maximum LTV 80%, minimum DSCR 1.25x), Lument (Fannie Mae DUS lender), accessed November 19, 2026
  2. How to calculate debt yield in CRE, Altus Group, accessed November 19, 2026
  3. Debt yield and its influence on structured debt, GlobeSt, accessed November 19, 2026

Azzets publishes education, research and commentary. Nothing on this site is investment, legal or tax advice, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Found an error? Tell us.